your ultimate cheat sheet to engagement ring shopping

everything you need to know before spending a dollar.

1. know your 4 Cs (but don’t obsess over them)

a diamond’s grading report is a starting point, but it doesn’t tell you everything about how the stone actually looks.

  • cut: how a diamond’s facets interact with light, affecting its sparkle. not to be confused with shape (oval, round, pear, etc.).

  • color: how colorless a diamond is, graded from d (colorless) to z (light yellow or brown).

  • clarity: the presence of internal inclusions and surface blemishes, graded from flawless (fl) to included (i3).

  • carat: the diamond’s weight, not its physical size. always check its dimensions in millimeters.

what do the color grades mean?

  • d–f: colorless. the highest color grades.

  • g–j: near colorless. minimal visible warmth.

  • k–m: faint color. subtle warmth.

  • n–r: very light color. more noticeable warmth.

  • s–z: light color. visible yellow or brown tones.

what about fancy-colored diamonds? diamonds with color beyond the d–z scale are graded separately using descriptions such as fancy light, fancy, fancy intense, and fancy vivid. unlike white diamonds, where less color generally means a higher grade, fancy-colored diamonds are valued for their hue, tone, and saturation. pink, blue, yellow, and brown diamonds can all fall into this category, although grading terminology varies by color.

what do clarity grades mean?

  • fl / if: flawless or internally flawless.

  • vvs1–vvs2: extremely minor inclusions.

  • vs1–vs2: minor inclusions, often invisible to the naked eye.

  • si1–si2: more noticeable inclusions, sometimes visible without magnification.

  • i1–i3: visible inclusions that may affect appearance or durability.

my take: don’t pay for perfection you can’t see. an eye-clean vs2 can look just as beautiful as a flawless diamond. and a d color diamond isn’t necessarily prettier than a k color diamond. beauty is subjective.

what the grading report won’t tell you

two diamonds with identical grades can look completely different. pay attention to:

  • bow ties: dark areas across elongated diamonds, especially ovals, pears, and marquise cuts.

  • windowing: areas where you can see through the diamond rather than reflected light.

  • light performance: how well the diamond reflects and returns light.

always request photos and videos in different lighting. a studio video isn’t necessarily how your diamond will look in real life.

2. color is subjective (let’s talk champagne)

champagne diamonds have warm yellow, brown, or pinkish undertones. some lab-grown champagne diamonds even command a premium because desirable tones can be difficult to produce consistently.

here’s how i personally categorize champagne tones, not an official grading system:

nude: g–j, barely-there warmth

light champagne: k–p, soft/warm tones

honey champagne: q–z, noticeable warmth

fancy champagne: fancy-color grades & richer, more saturated tones

the letter grade alone won’t tell you the undertone, make sure you see pictures and videos in different lighting!

my personal sweet spot is k–n with a brownish-pink or brownish-yellow tint.

browse our champagne diamonds

3. natural vs. lab: same diamond, different story

natural and lab-grown diamonds have the exact same chemical, physical, and optical properties. you can’t distinguish them with the naked eye.

  • natural: formed over billions of years, with a unique geological history and sentimental appeal.

  • lab-grown: created in a controlled environment, often costing 80–90% less than comparable natural diamonds, although prices vary.

my take: there’s no universally better choice. it comes down to your budget, priorities, and the sentiment you attach to the stone. but if you go lab-grown, who’s to say you won’t have a second ring down the road? (i have many clients with multiple engagement rings)

4. where you buy matters

  • jewelry stores: convenient, with in-person service, but storefront and marketing costs can influence pricing.

  • diamond dealers: often offer competitive pricing and a wider stone selection. bonus points if they can create the setting too.

  • auctions: avoid rushed purchases, especially on tiktok. i highly recommend NOT buying diamonds on auction unless you can review the diamond’s details and videos before committing.

always verify the grading report and ask about treatments, fluorescence, and certifications.

speaking of certifications… IGI vs. GIA: what’s the difference?

GIA (gemological institute of america) and IGI (international gemological institute) are two of the most recognized diamond grading laboratories. both independently evaluate diamonds based on their characteristics, but their grading standards and reporting practices can differ.

  • GIA: widely considered the industry benchmark for natural diamond grading. GIA developed the 4 cs and is known for its rigorous grading standards.

  • IGI: especially common for lab-grown diamonds and widely used for both natural and lab-grown stones. IGI reports traditionally include detailed color, clarity, and cut information, where applicable.

5. consider going custom

a fully custom diamond and setting can sometimes cost the same as an off-the-shelf ring, or even less, depending on the design.

and with big, brilliant, colorless lab diamonds everywhere, people are increasingly looking for something different:

  • rare colors

  • unique shapes

  • antique cuts

  • custom-cut diamonds

my take: you don’t have to settle for what’s in the display case. your ring can be completely your own.

6. the setting is half the ring

a gorgeous diamond in a poorly designed setting is still a bad ring.

profile and band

  • low-profile settings are less likely to snag or get knocked.

  • band width and thickness should provide enough support for the stone and setting. around 1.8–2 mm is a common starting point for many everyday designs, but requirements vary.

  • band cross section affects appearance and comfort:

    • half-round: classic and rounded.

    • flat: modern and architectural.

    • knife-edge: a distinctive raised ridge.

    • comfort fit: rounded inside for easier wear.

security

  • six prongs generally provide more redundancy than four, assuming comparable construction.

  • full bezels are among the most protective settings.

  • pointed shapes like pears and marquise cuts benefit from protected tips.

plan for your wedding band

some low-profile settings won’t allow a straight wedding band to sit flush.

consider a curved, offset, or notched band, or design the engagement ring to accommodate a straight band from the beginning.

7. durability: know her lifestyle

  • 14k gold is often harder and more scratch-resistant than 18k or 24k, although durability depends on the alloy and design.

  • for an active lifestyle, consider a sturdier band, low-profile setting, bezel, and matte finish to help camouflage everyday wear.

  • remove your ring during weightlifting, heavy manual work, or activities that could damage the setting or injure your finger.

my take: design your ring for the life you actually live.

8. romance is in the details

this is where a ring becomes hers:

  • hand engraving

  • mixed textures

  • sprinkled pavé diamonds

  • a personal message or date inside the band

  • birthstones

  • milgrain detailing

  • his and hers diamonds cut from the same rough

sometimes the smallest details are the most meaningful.

9. a few style opinions

in a lab-grown world, extra chunky gold is a flex.

and for my cool girls: consider asymmetrical settings, warped bands, unusual cuts, and sprinkled pavé.

forget the trends if they aren’t you.

10. most important: have fun with it

this is such an exciting time to be getting engaged. enjoy the creative process.

every choice, from the diamond to the tiniest engraving, is a reflection of your love story.

and the moment you finally see your finished ring? that’s what all of this is for.

tl;dr

  • don’t obsess over the 4 cs.

  • always see the diamond in different lighting.

  • color is subjective.

  • natural vs. lab is a personal choice.

  • where you buy matters.

  • consider going custom.

  • the setting is just as important as the diamond.

  • think about your lifestyle.

  • plan for your wedding band early.

  • don’t overlook the little details.

  • forget the trends if they aren’t you.

  • have fun with it!

looking for something specific?

from rare diamond colors and custom cuts to completely bespoke settings, we bring your dream jewelry to life.

book a free consultation

xoxo

cass @ notyourmomsdiamonds

Next
Next

engagement ring design considerations: because functionality is underrated